According to a Montour County coroner’s report, the cause of death of Amy Gregory, once next-door neighbor to 142 Carlisle Street, was determined to be drowning. The manner of death was not listed as suspicious. No details were provided in the report as to what evidence was used to determine the manner of death.
The report was signed on Feb. 11, 2023, the same date Gregory’s remains were found. Whether this tragic death merits further investigation in light of the recent murders at and connected to 142 Carlisle Street is ultimately up to Wilkes-Barre police.
My heartfelt condolences to the family of Amy Gregory.
Source for this update: Montour County, Pennsylvania, Coroner’s Report for Amy Gregory, signed Feb 11, 2023 by Scott E. Lynn II, Deputy Coroner; on file at the Montour County Prothonotary Office, Danville, Pennsylvania.
I grew up in Wilkes-Barre, and researching local history and genealogy is a hobby of mine. I learned from old newspaper articles that this section of Wilkes-Barre that includes 142 Carlisle Street was built on an old Native American burial ground. Seriously.
In the 1800s, it was the site of the E.W. Sturdevant Estate, also known as the Firwood Estate, until it was sold to developers in 1894. The Firwood Land Company began to develop the land and divide it into plots circa 1895.
As they were digging to build roads and later foundations, they unearthed several Native American burial sites, per newspaper reports of that time. See here and here. Some reports describe a vast burial ground stretching to the banks of the Susquehanna River, but I haven’t found any documentation to confirm it was that extensive.
Given this history, there’s a small chance the bones found in the basement on Carlisle Street, which was built on the former Sturdevant Estate, might be from an old burial ground. I write “small” chance because you’d think any burial sites would have been unearthed back when the foundation was dug.
But as the meme goes, the entire United States was built on an old Indian burial ground.
1904 Sanborn Map showing the E.W. Sturdevant Estate/Carlisle Street in Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania
A body was found behind the Host Inn in Wilkes-Barre, PA. Photo credit: NEPATrueCrime.com
After a day of much speculation on social media, the coroner, police chief, and DA have confirmed that the body found in the wooded area behind TGI Fridays/the Host Inn is connected to the 142 Carlisle Street investigation. That’s the house where a body was found buried in the basement. It’s also the former home of missing woman Debra Jane Fox.
Investigators are still working to obtain a positive investigation of both sets of remains, “each of which was found to have some degree of decomposition,” says the press release.
No further information is being released at this time due to the sensitive nature of the investigation.
Anyone with information related to this incident is urged to contact the Wilkes-Barre City Detective Division c/o Lt. Matthew Stash 570-208-0911 or Detective James Conmy 570-208-6775.
UPDATE Apr. 11, 2024: According to a Montour County coroner’s report, the cause of death of Amy Gregory, once next-door neighbor to 142 Carlisle Street, was determined to be drowning. The manner of death was not listed as suspicious. No details were provided in the report as to what evidence was used to determine the manner of death.
The report was signed on Feb. 11, 2023, the same date Gregory’s remains were found. Whether this tragic death merits further investigation in light of the recent murders at and connected to 142 Carlisle Street is ultimately up to Wilkes-Barre police.
My heartfelt condolences to the family of Amy Gregory.
Amy Gregory, 38, one-time next-door neighbor of missing Wilkes-Barre woman Debra Jane Fox, vanished in December 2022 and was found dead near or in a river in Feb 2023.
Although the cases might be completely unconnected, the coincidence is significant enough to mention here.
Gregory had lived at 140 Carlisle St, part of the same row of houses and immediately next door to 142 Carlisle St, where human remains were discovered buried in the basement on Feb. 27, 2024. News reports from the time of her disappearance describe Gregory as living in nearby Kingston, PA, but 140 Carlisle appears to have been her family home.
Screenshot from PeopleFinders.com, showing Amy Gregory’s association with the 140 Carlisle Street address.
Amy Gregory was last seen at about 5:30 p.m. on Dec. 21, 2022, leaving home on foot to see her children’s father [he has not been named publicly]. Her family reported her missing the following day, Dec. 22. She was six months pregnant.
Tragically, her remains were discovered on Feb. 11, 2023, by individuals walking near the Susquehanna River in Montour County. The discovery was made near Sharp Ridge and Susquehanna roads in Mayberry Township, about 50 miles southwest of Wilkes-Barre. An unofficial source states her body was found floating in the river.
Amy Gregory was found in the area near Sharp Ridge and Susquehanna roads in Mayberry Township
The local fire department assisted at the scene to recover the body from the difficult terrain, per a news report. State police from Stonington, Milton, Montoursville, and Wilkes-Barre City Police also assisted.
The last update I can find about this case is from Feb 21, 2023, when Montour County Coroner Scott Lynn told Eyewitness News that the cause and manner of Gregory’s death are pending further investigation and testing results.
This is such a terrible case. Not only did she disappear just a few days before Christmas, but she was six months pregnant. She was also the mother of two children.
Anyone with information is urged to contact Detective Andres at 570-208-4128 or the Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers at 1-800-4PA-TIPS.
This is a screenshot from a GoFundMe for funeral costs, with a comment from Danielle Fox, daughter of missing woman Debra Fox, that says “A good neighbor and friend will be missed.”
On March 12, 2024, authorities retrieved a body from the Susquehanna River near the Kirby Park side of the Market Street Bridge. Since then, there have been no updates regarding the identity of the individual or the circumstances surrounding their death.
The body was found floating face-down in the swiftly flowing river, which was experiencing higher-than-normal water levels of 13 feet at the time. This water level is considered elevated for this section of the Susquehanna.
The above is literally the only information I can find about this case, so I’ve created this blog post to keep tabs on it.
Update March 28, 2024: Officials announced the body found in the woods behind TGI Fridays/hotels is linked to the 142 Carlisle St. death investigation, at the former home of missing Wilkes-Barre woman Debra Fox.
March 27, 2024
What is up with the recent spate of unidentified remains in Wilkes-Barre? We still haven’t had an update about the body found in the Susquehanna River near Kirby Park on March 12. And the investigation into the remains found in a basement at 142 Carlisle Street in Wilkes-Barre is ongoing.
Yesterday, authorities found a body in the area behind the TGI Fridays on Kidder Street in Wilkes-Barre. This location is part of a complex that includes three 2-star hotels: the Host Inn All Suites, Wilkes-Barre Inn & Suites, and Fairfield Inn.
The Times Leader reported that a significant police presence, including Wilkes-Barre police and state troopers, arrived at the scene shortly before noon on Tuesday, March 26, 2024. The body was discovered at the bottom of a steep embankment in a wooded area behind the Host Inn All Suites Hotel.
The terrain was so dense that the Public Works Department had to clear access using chainsaws and pole saws. Wooden planks were also used to create makeshift steps on the steep slope. Luzerne County Coroner Jill Matthews removed the body shortly before 3 p.m.
PaHomePage spoke with a Wilkes-Barre man who said told them he’s observed police searching the woods behind the hotel for months. “I’ve seen them coming in and out; detectives have been digging every day,” he said.
Really?
Police Chief Joseph Coffay told the Times Leader more information will be released later.
