Finally! Robert Baron Murder Trial Starts Today

The Robert Baron murder trial has started today, Monday, May 6, 2024. The trial is expected to take about two weeks, beginning with jury selection today.

I think most locals will agree this case has haunted Northeastern Pennsylvania ever since Robert Baron went missing under suspicious circumstances in late January 2017. He was the owner of the iconic Old Forge restaurant Ghigiarelli’s — a 100-year-old establishment. Gruesome details about his disappearance made the news, such as the discovery of blood and a tooth at Baron’s family-owned establishment. Billboards pleading for help solving the case were constant reminders of this horrible mystery, which went unsolved for six long years.

Justin Schuback, 38, of Foundry Street in Old Forge, who was an associate of Robert Baron’s son, was arrested on March 31, 2023. He is charged with:

• Murder Of The First Degree
• Murder Of The Second Degree
•Murder Of The Third Degree Robbery-Inflict Serious Bodily Injury
• Burglary – Overnight Accommodations; Person Present, Bodily Injury Crime Theft By Unlaw Taking-Movable Prop
• Criminal Homicide
• Abuse Of Corpse

Shuback pleaded not guilty to all charges at his June 2023 preliminary hearing, despite the fact it was his cell-tower data that led police straight to Robert Baron’s remains.

Sources

[Paywall] Murder trial in death of Robert Baron set to start Monday, The Citizen’s Voice, May 4, 2024

Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas Docket for Justin Shuback

ICYMI: Recent NEPA True Crime News

In case you missed it. Select local crime headlines from the past week or so:

Murderous ‘trick roll’ in Nanticoke? Local PD and State Troopers nvestigating this death and similar incidents.

A “trick roll” is a scam using the false promise of sex for money to rob a would-be customer. Victims of the scheme usually don’t report the con. But when the mark dies, it speaks volumes to law enforcement. The suspicious death of 36-year-old Mark J. Harrison in Nanticoke is under investigation after he was found deceased in his home on April 14 from a possible drug overdose. Law enforcement sources suggest that one or two women, possibly advertised as prostitutes on social media, might have intended to induce the overdose to steal from Harrison.

In 1931, a man who lived at 142 Carlisle Street ‘House of Horrors’ was murdered with an icepick.


The Times Leader’s Look Back column by Ed Lewis reports on the 1931 murder of George H. Belles, who was living at 142 Carlisle Street. Belles was murdered by a coworker with an icepick and died in Mercy Hospital.

Milford man charged with killing grandmother “She was the devil I had to do it.”

George Sisco, 28, believed his grandmother was the devil and brutally attacked and murdered her when he saw her applying flea medication to the cat. According to court documents, Sisco believed she was poisoning the pet and initially attacked her with his fists and then with a knife, stabbing her in the chest and later setting her body on fire.


Missing local woman was informant on dangerous Brooklyn gang; endured brutal beating and torture requiring reconstructive surgery during FBI investigation.

[Paywall] The Citizens Voice published an in-depth feature on the case of Danielle Marie Drozdowski, who was 25 years old when she vanished in the spring of 2014. Family members and court documents reveal that in the months leading up to her disappearance, Drozdowski became involved with members of a notorious gang and a gangster rap group from Brooklyn, New York.

GoFundMe Set Up for Wilkes-Barre homicide victim Nicole Cuevas

The family of homicide victim Nicole Cuevas, whose remains were buried in the basement of 142 Carlisle Street in Wilkes-Barre, has set up a GoFundMe. The fundraiser was established by Paris Scroggins, Cuevas’ younger brother.

The GoFundMe page says all money raised will go toward transporting Cuevas’ remains to Michigan, funeral costs, traveling back and forth from Michigan to Pennsylvania for trial dates, and helping with unanticipated costs related to funeral and burial costs.

Scroggins wrote, “My sister was a good person and neither her nor her family deserves what happened.”

Visit the GoFundMe here: https://gofund.me/2ee60183

Update: Montour County Coroner ruled Amy Gregory’s death not suspicious

According to a Montour County coroner’s report, the cause of death of Amy Gregory, once next-door neighbor to 142 Carlisle Street, was determined to be drowning. The manner of death was not listed as suspicious. No details were provided in the report as to what evidence was used to determine the manner of death.

The report was signed on Feb. 11, 2023, the same date Gregory’s remains were found. Whether this tragic death merits further investigation in light of the recent murders at and connected to 142 Carlisle Street is ultimately up to Wilkes-Barre police. 

My heartfelt condolences to the family of Amy Gregory.

Source for this update: Montour County, Pennsylvania, Coroner’s Report for Amy Gregory, signed Feb 11, 2023 by Scott E. Lynn II, Deputy Coroner; on file at the Montour County Prothonotary Office, Danville, Pennsylvania.